.svg)
If you’ve tried online therapy platforms like BetterHelp or Talkspace—or are considering signing up—you’re not alone. Millions of people have turned to virtual mental health marketplaces hoping for relief, connection, and meaningful growth. But many walk away feeling underwhelmed.
If you're searching for a more structured, skills-based, and community-centered alternative to BetterHelp, you're in the right place.
At TheraHive, we do things differently—and we think that matters.
The Rise (and Limitations) of Online Therapy Platforms
BetterHelp and Talkspace have exploded in popularity by promising easy, on-demand access to licensed therapists via app or web. For a weekly subscription, users can text or video-chat with a therapist from anywhere. These online therapy platforms grew to fill a gap in mental health care – especially during the pandemic when in-person therapy was hard to get. Their convenience and anonymity appeal to people who might not otherwise seek therapy.
However, not all experiences on these platforms are positive. Beneath the glossy marketing, many users and experts have noted serious drawbacks. BetterHelp, for instance, reportedly spent over $100 million on advertising in 2023, and its ads boast “30,000+ therapists” ready to help. Yet high volume and aggressive marketing can come at a cost to quality. In fact, a clinical psychologist who went undercover as a client on BetterHelp (source) “came away with serious concerns” about the platform’s ability to provide quality, secure treatment. She found the actual therapy disappointingly shallow—what she described as confusing, detached, and algorithmic. In her words, “BetterHelp seems better suited to those hoping to dip a toe into therapy rather than those seeking sustained, high-quality care.” This gap between promise and reality has led many users to seek an alternative.
Talkspace, likewise, gained fame (and venture capital) by offering text-based therapy and even psychiatric services online. It became a household name through celebrity endorsements and insurance partnerships. But as its user base grew, so did reports of impersonal or unhelpful experiences. Even some influencers who tried Talkspace have spoken out. For example, YouTuber Elle Mills described her Talkspace experience, saying “the whole process felt impersonal and rushed. It didn’t help me at all.” Such feedback echoes countless Reddit threads and reviews from people who felt these apps didn’t provide the support they expected.
In short, BetterHelp and Talkspace deserve credit for increasing access to therapy. Yet their one-size-fits-all, marketplace approach has inherent limitations. Let’s examine some of the common criticisms of these platforms – and see why people are searching for something better.
Common Criticisms of BetterHelp and Talkspace
(Both BetterHelp and Talkspace have been widely criticized for issues related to care quality, program structure, and trust. Common user complaints include:
- Inconsistent Care Quality: With thousands of therapists on each platform, user experiences can vary significantly. While some users find helpful connections, many others report feeling mismatched with providers who lack specialization in their issues. The Mad in America article documents a clinical psychologist's experience with BetterHelp, where two out of three therapists failed to meet basic standards of care.
- Lack of Structure: Many users describe their sessions as aimless or repetitive. Many BetterHelp users say they feel like they’re “just talking” without direction. At TheraHive, every session is structured to teach practical strategies you can apply immediately. This is especially frustrating for those seeking tangible strategies to manage their mental health.
- Limited Therapist Support and Oversight: Therapists on these platforms typically work independently, with minimal oversight or support. This means they may be juggling high caseloads, receiving little feedback, and operating without collaboration or supervision—factors that can affect the quality of care.
- Privacy and Data Concerns: BetterHelp faced scrutiny after a 2023 FTC settlement for sharing sensitive mental health data with advertisers. Talkspace has also faced questions about how it handles user data and communications, adding to user concerns about confidentiality.
- Impersonal Experience: Both platforms promote ease and access, but many users report feeling like just another number. Sessions often feel rushed, and relationships can be transactional. Reddit threads like this one are filled with stories of users feeling dismissed, unsupported, or unheard.
In short, while these platforms have made therapy more accessible, they often fall short in delivering the kind of consistent, skill-focused, and accountable care that many users are ultimately looking for.)
TheraHive: A High-Integrity Alternative Focused on Skills and Community
TheraHive takes a very different approach to online mental health support. Instead of the traditional one-on-one, text-heavy therapy marketplace, TheraHive offers group-based, skills-oriented psychoeducation. Specifically, it provides live online courses where a small group of participants learn and practice Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT) skills together, led by a trained coach. It’s a model built on quality, structure, and community – essentially the opposite of the "Wild West" feel that some online platforms have.
Evidence-Based Curriculum (Real Skills for Life)
TheraHive's program is grounded in Dialectical Behavior Therapy principles but delivered through a flexible, engaging learning format. Our curriculum is designed to accommodate a wide range of learning styles—whether you're a visual learner, someone who thrives on discussion, or someone who benefits from structured reflection. Learn more about how our unique courses are designed to support diverse learners in this blog post.
TheraHive isn’t just about talking – it’s a curriculum-driven program. Participants progress through a structured course covering modules like Mindfulness, Distress Tolerance, Emotion Regulation, and Interpersonal Effectiveness.
Small Group Learning with Peer Support
Unlike solitary app-based therapy, TheraHive emphasizes community. Participants learn together in small, supportive groups where peer validation and shared accountability drive engagement and progress.
Highly Trained Coaches
TheraHive works with a small number of highly trained coaches. These coaches receive ongoing supervision and meet regularly to review student progress – a far cry from the loosely monitored contractor networks used by platforms like BetterHelp and Talkspace.
Transparent, Affordable, and Ethical
We also help participants set clear, achievable goals from the outset. By learning how to apply SMART goal-setting principles, students stay focused and motivated throughout the program. You can read more about our approach to goal-setting in this blog post.
TheraHive offers clear pricing, no surprise subscriptions, and prioritizes participant privacy. It is a high-integrity, educational experience, not a therapy replacement, but a powerful complement or entry point to personal growth.
Why People Are Choosing TheraHive
If you’re looking for:
- A more structured, evidence-based learning experience
- A strong sense of community and support
- Practical coping skills you can use in daily life
- A consistent and ethical support model
...then TheraHive may be exactly what you need.
What Our Participants Say
“I learned more in three weeks at TheraHive than I did in six months of therapy. The structure, the group connection, the clarity—it just works.”
— Program Participant, 2024
“I used BetterHelp for a while but felt like I was spinning in circles. TheraHive gave me tools I use every day.”
— Former BetterHelp user
{{promo-banner-1}}
Final Thoughts
Searching for a BetterHelp alternative or Talkspace alternative doesn’t mean therapy failed you. It may mean that you need a different format. TheraHive offers a thoughtful, group-based psychoeducational experience designed to help you build real skills in a supportive, engaging environment. Check out Reddit or read the Mad in America article if you want to hear what others are saying.
Then, come back to TheraHive. We’re building a better way to grow.
.svg)
.svg)
.png)